| | Joseph Emerson Carnahan 1860–1936 | | |
John David Carnahan 1864–… | | |
| | Clarren Simeon Carnahan 1869–1940 Olla Mae Ollie Deisler 1872–1937 | | |
Martha Estella Carnahan 1874–… | | |
| | Elizabeth Myers 1835–1905 | | |
| | John Carnahan, Sr. 1803–1867 Anna Hutchinson 1808–1891 | | |
| | David Carnahan, Sr. 1745–1825 Jane Hutchinson 1750–1840 | | |